Howdy,
I have some questions regarding methods to get optimal live sound in pd.
Using my electric guitar, I keep running into situations where the mix and loudness levels vary widely form place to place and system to system. I am used to this happening with regular analog gear, but not with the rather annoying difficulties it adds in pd. I run into feedback problems with the guitar or the mic, the mix sounds weak, etc. I just cannot seem to get a good, consistent live sound when using the electric and a live mic .. *sigh*.
So my questions are:
What do you guys do for your live set? Do you do some sort of EQ/compression on the final stage before going out the the dac~? I found this post about the ears response to certain frequencies at different sound pressure levels http://gabesrocklog.blogspot.com/2009/08/eq-or-how-to-turn-down-suck-knob.ht.... Should I try using these curves on an eq going out? Does anyone know how commercial software deals with this? It seems to me that Logic, Live, etc must have some sort of input/output compensation that I would need to replicate in order to have a more uniform sound across the board? Is this just subjective and /or not possible?
Thanks for any ideas ...
Dan Wilcox danomatika.com robotcowboy.com
On Sun, 22 Nov 2009, Dan Wilcox wrote:
What do you guys do for your live set? Do you do some sort of EQ/compression on the final stage before going out the the dac~?
A little bit of chaos theory... suppose you apply a filter on sound, and you take into account the net gain of the feedback, and you call all of it as f(x). What can you expect f(f(x)) to be? f(f(f(x))) ? f(f(f(f(x)))) ? and so on. This tells you what happens with feedback.
If you have a compressor that systematically takes whatever there is and divides the dB by any fraction above 1 (e.g. by 1.1 such that -55 dB becomes -50 dB), then in «silence» it will pick up any tiny noise at the smallest noninfinite dB and will divide its dB by 1.1 many times until it becomes extremely loud. That's unstable feedback. (Stable feedback is when the dB of the echo is going down, but this fading out could be at any speed, even if it's slow.)
Therefore you can't add a plain compressor without aggravating any existing feedback, however tiny it is. You need to use something even more nonlinear than that, by adding something like a noisegate component. (nonlinear means anything not made by adding proportional parts).
I found this post about the ears response to certain frequencies at different sound pressure levels http://gabesrocklog.blogspot.com/2009/08/eq-or-how-to-turn-down-suck-knob.ht.... Should I try using these curves on an eq going out?
Those show you what's the gain in the ear. That doesn't tell you about the gain in your speakers, the gain in your amplifier, nor the gain due to reflection (vs absorption) on walls.
_ _ __ ___ _____ ________ _____________ _____________________ ... | Mathieu Bouchard, Montréal, Québec. téléphone: +1.514.383.3801
Hi Dan
Am 22.11.09 21:15 schrieb "Dan Wilcox" unter danomatika@gmail.com:
What do you guys do for your live set? Do you do some sort of EQ/compression on the final stage before going out the the dac~?
This applies only to generated live music, that is not using live input. I usually setup my usual chain of one or two compressors followed by a limiter. When using two compressors, the first one uses rather long attack and release times with rather lower threshold (which does some basic levelling), while the second 'kinks' the peaks by using a short attack and release and a higher threshold. And the limiter does - yeah, limiting.
While being often not a friend of too much post-processing, i found it can help a lot to make the the output sound more balanced and more pleasing to the ear in difficult acoustic situations. I remember once when we had a netpd live session on the radio, i was surprised how punchy even a 'naked' saw can sound (after having passed all the stages, that prepare the signal for broadcasting).
The compressor and limiter mentioned above can be downloaded (and have zexy as a depencency): http://www.netpd.org/Dynlib
Roman
Telefonate ohne weitere Kosten vom PC zum PC: http://messenger.yahoo.de
Roman Haefeli wrote:
Hi Dan
Am 22.11.09 21:15 schrieb "Dan Wilcox" unter danomatika@gmail.com:
What do you guys do for your live set? Do you do some sort of EQ/compression on the final stage before going out the the dac~?
The compressor and limiter mentioned above can be downloaded (and have zexy as a depencency): http://www.netpd.org/Dynlib
Are the ones you're talking about those included in Pdmtl fx section?
++ OH
Am 25.11.09 12:25 schrieb "Oli44" unter olivier@heinry.fr:
Roman Haefeli wrote:
Hi Dan
Am 22.11.09 21:15 schrieb "Dan Wilcox" unter danomatika@gmail.com:
What do you guys do for your live set? Do you do some sort of EQ/compression on the final stage before going out the the dac~?
The compressor and limiter mentioned above can be downloaded (and have zexy as a depencency): http://www.netpd.org/Dynlib
Are the ones you're talking about those included in Pdmtl fx section?
Right.. thanks for mentioning. Those are probably much easier to use than the netpd-ized versions.
Roman
Telefonate ohne weitere Kosten vom PC zum PC: http://messenger.yahoo.de