Hi folks, i'm wrestling away with the schedule functions for Scheme-for-Pd, and I think I can make things a lot more reliable if I let every instantiation (or restart) of the scheme interpreter have a uid of some sort so that on a reset we can just ignore clocks running out on a previous instance instead of trying to clean them all up with manual memory management. (which approach is giving me segfaults because I'm screwing something up)
Can anyone tell me what a smart way of getting a unique identifier would be? It doesn't need to be unique across the world, just the local machine, so something that was seeded from system time would be fine. I'm not a Real C Programmer though, so am not clear what options will just work across all OS's, without needing to add dependencies.
thanks!
Hi,
this is a bit of a XY question. The actual problem is about managing clocks. Let's see if we can find a proper solution.
I would assume that you are storing the clock(s) alongside the interpreter instance. If you restart the interpret, unset the clock(s) with clock_unset(). If you free the instance, free the clock(s) with clock_free().
If that somehow doesn't work for you, explain the exact problem and show the code.
---
It doesn't need to be unique across the world, just the local machine
Why would your ID even need to be unique across the whole machine? I think it should be enough that it's unique within the app. In that case, you can simply use the memory address of the interpreter instance itself. In fact, that's how Pd creates the canvas and object IDs for communicating with the Tcl/Tk GUI app.
Christof
On 12.06.2021 18:50, Iain Duncan wrote:
Hi folks, i'm wrestling away with the schedule functions for Scheme-for-Pd, and I think I can make things a lot more reliable if I let every instantiation (or restart) of the scheme interpreter have a uid of some sort so that on a reset we can just ignore clocks running out on a previous instance instead of trying to clean them all up with manual memory management. (which approach is giving me segfaults because I'm screwing something up)
Can anyone tell me what a smart way of getting a unique identifier would be? It doesn't need to be unique across the world, just the local machine, so something that was seeded from system time would be fine. I'm not a Real C Programmer though, so am not clear what options will just work across all OS's, without needing to add dependencies.
thanks!
Pd-dev mailing list Pd-dev@lists.iem.at https://lists.puredata.info/listinfo/pd-dev
Hi Christof, you are right, it was a bad idea, but the good news is that in the hours since I posted that I managed to get it to work properly. It's been a while since I did data structures manually in C... :-)
I went for maintaining a double-linked list of clock_info structures that just stores them as they come in. If the interpreter is reset, or object freed, or we make a cancel-clocks request, that just gets walked with all clocks unset, freed, and the memory for the clock info nodes freed. In normal operation, no extra walking needs to happen as the (not cancelled) callback takes ownership of the pointers and cleans up as part of it's execution. The implementation could certainly be more elegant, but it seems to be robust (not sure I even need the double linking, but it helped me think about it...) I made a fuzzy tester that assaults the object with variable tempo'd delay requests, requests to cancel 1 delay, and requests to cancel all, and resets and I can't make it crash anymore, even recreating the object. Phew!
Thanks for the help everyone. Will post to the list when the next cut is ready.
iain
On Sat, Jun 12, 2021 at 2:28 PM Christof Ressi info@christofressi.com wrote:
Hi,
this is a bit of a XY question. The actual problem is about managing clocks. Let's see if we can find a proper solution.
I would assume that you are storing the clock(s) alongside the interpreter instance. If you restart the interpret, unset the clock(s) with clock_unset(). If you free the instance, free the clock(s) with clock_free().
If that somehow doesn't work for you, explain the exact problem and show the code.
It doesn't need to be unique across the world, just the local machine
Why would your ID even need to be unique across the whole machine? I think it should be enough that it's unique within the app. In that case, you can simply use the memory address of the interpreter instance itself. In fact, that's how Pd creates the canvas and object IDs for communicating with the Tcl/Tk GUI app.
Christof On 12.06.2021 18:50, Iain Duncan wrote:
Hi folks, i'm wrestling away with the schedule functions for Scheme-for-Pd, and I think I can make things a lot more reliable if I let every instantiation (or restart) of the scheme interpreter have a uid of some sort so that on a reset we can just ignore clocks running out on a previous instance instead of trying to clean them all up with manual memory management. (which approach is giving me segfaults because I'm screwing something up)
Can anyone tell me what a smart way of getting a unique identifier would be? It doesn't need to be unique across the world, just the local machine, so something that was seeded from system time would be fine. I'm not a Real C Programmer though, so am not clear what options will just work across all OS's, without needing to add dependencies.
thanks!
Pd-dev mailing listPd-dev@lists.iem.athttps://lists.puredata.info/listinfo/pd-dev
-
Christof Ressi -
Iain Duncan