Any statement in a license can't just be disregarded. That's a very clear statement within a license, so its legally binding. And therefore PiDiP is not free software.
I'd prefer to have that phrase removed from the PiDiP license, though I agree with its sentiment. Otherwise it will make distributing PiDiP difficult, among other things.
.hc
On Dec 29, 2005, at 8:48 PM, Marc Lavallée wrote:
Le 29 Décembre 2005 21:56, Mathieu Bouchard a écrit :
On Fri, 30 Dec 2005 ydegoyon@free.fr wrote:
we know it's all copyright, all your fake free software attitude ....
I found this in PiDiP's LICENSE.txt :
"NOT FOR MILITARY OR REPRESSIVE USE !!!"
This goes against FSF/GNU's FSD, rule "Freedom Zero" (http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/free-sw.html)
Yes. But this is only because the FSF wants the user to decide what's good or bad.
And also against OSI's OSD, rule 6 (http://www.opensource.org/docs/definition.php)
Wrong interpretation: the term "military or repressive use" does not relate to any speficic activity, because so many fields of endeavor are involved in the business of repression. But it complies with rule 5: "No Discrimination Against Persons or Groups", because using force against people usually involves discrimination.
And as such, PiDiP is not Free Software. It may not be distributed as part of Debian's "main" and thus instead should be put in "non-free".
It's a "modified" BSD licence, it's open and compatible... But this first phrase is simply an opinion, and legally almost irrelevent. It's a bit weird to use a BSD license and add such a vague statement, knowing that OpenBSD was financed by the Pentagon for many years until Theo de Raadt expressed its concern about the war in Iraq. B.T.W. the Internet was also developed by the Pentagon, so maybe PiDiP should not be downloaded from the Internet, since this network is being used for war and repression.
It's not a good idea to add "politically correct" clauses in a license, because their interpretations can be too fuzzy. A license is a technical document, and moral stances are better included as "legal embodiments", like the GPL does so well.
Help, help! I'm being opressed! (Monty Python and the Holy Grail) ;-) -- Marc
PD-dev mailing list PD-dev@iem.at http://lists.puredata.info/listinfo/pd-dev
________________________________________________________________________ ____
"I have the audacity to believe that peoples everywhere can have three meals a day for their bodies, education and culture for their minds, and dignity, equality and freedom for their spirits." - Martin Luther King, Jr.