On Sun, Oct 09, 2011 at 07:52:34PM -0400, Hans-Christoph Steiner wrote:
Most Pd people using the SF tracker aren't aware of its details, (I guess me included since I didn't know the order).
Come to think of it, JIRA makes this more obvious by graying out the links on all the older files.
I think it makes a lot more transparent if there is only one copy of the files there, unless there is a specific reason to have both copies of the patch there, like two different approaches.
In this particular case, there was a bug in the first patch which was corrected in the second. I was hesitant to remove the first because I figured committer review would be easier if you could see how the two patches had changed.
Then the third patch obsoleted both of them by being faster, correct (as far as I can tell, better than patch 1 at least), and easier to grok. It does take a different approach, particularly in u8_charnum(), and that contrast has been lost. But oh well.
Marvin Humphrey