hi all,
i was thinking about adding some non-blocking message
queue mechanism to pd, to simplify writing externals
with their own worker threads that cannot, by design,
block the audio thread.
i've found the need for this in almost all of my pd
projects that use threads, and the only one that has
solved it somewhat properly is wvvw.. adding support
to pd would prevent a lot of hassle. it could serve as
an 'external design pattern' actually.
this could be implemented in the form of a pd-message
queue. even a simple fixed size ringbuffer containing fixed
size pd atoms would be a very nice thing to have as a standard
part of pd. it doesn't require platform-specific code,
and doesn't use dynamic memory allocation for each message.
this can catch most of the communication needed between the
main pd thread and a bunch of isolated worker threads, and do
it in a way that forces you to not cause drops.
something like:
typedef struct {
t_atom *buffer;
int length; // single message length in atoms
int size; // total number of messages
int read; // read atom index
int write; // write atom index
} t_queue;
t_atom *queue_read(t_queue *q); // returns NULL if queue empty
int queue_write(t_queue *q, t_atom *a); // returns error code if full
void queue_free(t_queue *q);
t_queue *queue_new(int length, int size);
another thing that i've been looking for, is a standard
way to hook into the main scheduler loop to add a poll
hook. you can do this with clocks, but an explicit hook at
the point where the gui is polled for updates would be much
cleaner. maybe 2 hooks: one that runs at the dsp tick, and
one that runs at gui tick.
so the pattern is:
thread->pd: a message queue with poller in pd scheduler
pd->thread: another message queue with poller in worker thread
the pollers are application-specific, but some could be included
in the pd api, like a poller that sends messages to a certain object,
or a receiving symbol. this is not really necessary though.
my apologies if i missed out one some discussion on this subject,
but i think this would be trivial to add and very useful.
tom