whatever you think is a reasonable feature, is reasonable for at least one person (yourself), which i think is good enough to post as a feature request.
True. I plan on adding them.
however, i'm a bit disappointed by statements like "this isn’t mentioned at all on the bug tracker". first of all, these are not bugs at all, but missing features at best.
Better to refer to it as an issue? I know they're not bugs, but I can't think of a generic term that would work across all sites. On Sourceforge they're referred to as tickets, on Github issues. Which is better or more accurate to use?
having said that, i would like to have both features (automagically turning a part of the patch into a subpatch/abstraction; inserting objects) in Pd.
y'see the fact that this wasn't on the bug/issue/feature tracker suggested to me that no one else wanted to see these features implemented. I'm glad I'm not the only one.
btw, i found inserting objects not to be such a big deal: i'm mostly live-coding audio in Pd (and btw, i insist on calling it live-coding, rather than "live-patching"...but this is probably because i think that i do write code rather than merely stacking objects together), and i found that it is entirely possible to re-wire audio-signals without lengthy silences. when doing graphics only this problem appears to be even less prominent.
Correct, but with code/object insertion this wouldn't be an issue at all and there would be no blackouts.
On 5 May 2014 08:48, IOhannes m zmoelnig zmoelnig@iem.at wrote:
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA256
On 2014-05-01 14:52, Antonio Roberts wrote:
I admit that my suggestions towards the end do need more thought behind them, but as a starting point do they seem like reasonable requests?
whatever you think is a reasonable feature, is reasonable for at least one person (yourself), which i think is good enough to post as a feature request.
however, i'm a bit disappointed by statements like "this isn’t mentioned at all on the bug tracker". first of all, these are not bugs at all, but missing features at best. more importantly, the people responsible for posting feature requests are those that require those features...in this case this is you.
having said that, i would like to have both features (automagically turning a part of the patch into a subpatch/abstraction; inserting objects) in Pd.
btw, i found inserting objects not to be such a big deal: i'm mostly live-coding audio in Pd (and btw, i insist on calling it live-coding, rather than "live-patching"...but this is probably because i think that i do write code rather than merely stacking objects together), and i found that it is entirely possible to re-wire audio-signals without lengthy silences. when doing graphics only this problem appears to be even less prominent.
fgmadr IOhannes
PS: iirc, desiredata had all these features by 2007... -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: GnuPG v1 Comment: Using GnuPG with Icedove - http://www.enigmail.net/
iQIcBAEBCAAGBQJTZ0JhAAoJELZQGcR/ejb43JcP/i2u4lTQClOiddXfKzRBK/lC lJg9cwviruCu+K8OHhfLioz7BLP71BFrG7MF7XXSC5uyE21pxNENB50k4UB6r3yo V6FztR9kymFc1wJ0zPiq7OHhFfwuX6JwgKGctTkX40ZjigGum4T8SDpzxD4lZyLh bZ9zQUzHyd/CDJ2/8BRAhzSxKguOu3ZH8m6TOn8LdDBVPXkXapxOAjxVDyUyL/lI apIuSF0y9n5sd+DNjpY75Oz/gUucXLxr1r+TKkxhgh1MFgf8K7UAFvl9ZptgjgD2 x69Ln9onYVsFzZ8GSH8C3FXSnBVMmp+diXOwUzfRdhK6Lx59PPw9Z9ek+c9oBUwq ralm0wu+N0Z4zkbrUbL5eqCBygPxvFlUt/00drI5gGZoOTnVShwfPK9ULcdWl89Z UVH1VwxarCGc3xY+nvqweXQ1A03VKR7YNTFAaoY5nRDlD8CPx5dd2YGNgHNAEy8U rNvdtZxTbC2xXFtcJJ68K6QyoMYx1mSei+BGcAfYxuWBtcTG+L3roVi5emnYgZzO w0XLUGT6YgGEVoqRXip/1wiRRlW4Fy9AgkpNa+z6heK8/xeulZV52oyiiDZ+mZ7D R1zxwkHV5unJBO6+whANTQGsFBcflQhBHvsBgZg5pxCRXpZqR4WFDxOJKVpKqExT d4a9yyYS2IUvKh+qMibc =RXrf -----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
Pd-ot mailing list Pd-ot@iem.at http://lists.puredata.info/listinfo/pd-ot