hi, 

pix_multiblob algorithm changes just after the 0.93.3 release in november 2011
Ricardo Fabbri made those changes so maybe he is the best person to help us figuring out where the "bug" is, if this is really a bug

since the algorithm changed I'm not so surprised that the same patch with the same parameters doesn't work in both case

if pix_multiblob should be backward compatible, could it be possible to rename the Ricardo's version to pix_multiblob2 or something else and to restore the 0.93.3's version in the Gem's main trunk ?
or is it better to put the two algorithms in the same pix_multiblob object and select it with a [mode( message or something else ?

cheers

a

 


--
do it yourself                      
http://antoine.villeret.free.fr


2013/6/15 IOhannes m zmölnig <zmoelnig@iem.at>
On 06/15/13 16:03, Max wrote:
> So that is a confirmed Gem problem. I don't see the point to work with that object any more, now that I know that the new version breaks backward compatibility. I want to be able to make a patch that works with whatever gem version : (

i think that' a bitter conclusion to draw.
obviously the object should be backwards compatible, and it being not is
a bug.

rather than ranting about "not seeing the point any mor" it would be
good to help fix the bug.

fgdstn
IOhannes



_______________________________________________
Pd-list@iem.at mailing list
UNSUBSCRIBE and account-management -> http://lists.puredata.info/listinfo/pd-list