2017-03-06 18:22 GMT-03:00 Dan Wilcox <danomatika@gmail.com>:
anyway was this not all discussed and decided upon in pdx dev days?

I think it was ~/pd-externals, at least that’s what I still use.

Well, I did navigate through old threads on this list to catch up. There was a lengthy discussion about linux, which led to change it from ~/pd-externals to ~/.local/lib/pd/extra. 

Apparently, most felt it was annoying the creation of a ~/pd-externals folder and how weird and uncommon that standard folder was. Thus, there's this new option for a standard folder...

Though, once the new standard is valid, I saw no discussion or resistance to the idea of that folder being created for the user. In fact I saw Roman asking something this:


I believe yet all have agreed to ~/.local/lib/pd/extra as the default
install path (and most recent Deken uses it).

There was some concerns about creating directories without asking. Now,
do those concerns still apply with above default install path? It seems
pretty normal that applications do stuff there. Is anyone still against
auto-creating? 

Roman

source: https://lists.puredata.info/pipermail/pd-list/2016-06/115306.html

Well, there was no response and no formal opposition to that... there was also many aspects of the "deken user install expeerience" discussion that was inconclusive, as it died out when the release was made. Maybe it's time to pick that discussion up and do some improvements for the next release.

Moreover, I saw nothing discussed about the creation of folders in MacOs or Windows, nor how weird/bad the choice was. Me, Mark and Dan have a consensus here how the ~/Library folder is a bad choice. So maybe we can follow the trend form Linux and change it to a better place like ~/Documents

But one thing is deciding of a good standard folder, the other discussion is if Pd should create such folders. Is there any concern but the old discussion that creating ~/pd-externals in linux was a bad call?

I can't see any reason why a software can't create user and system folders when it needs to. And right now this is making it really harder than it should to install externals in Pd (just saying).

 
BTW arduino and processing also both install libraries in:

~/Documents

and as porres might say "just saying"

m

would you also just say (as I might) that they do create such folders for you and no one gets hurt in the process? ;)

cheers