On 06/07/2015 11:33 AM, Martin Peach wrote:
On Sat, Jun 6, 2015 at 9:52 PM, Jonathan Wilkes via Pd-list <pd-list@lists.iem.at> wrote:
Hi list,
tldr; Sourceforge has bundled malware with older Windows binaries for Gimp and apparently moved an old Sourceforge repo for nmap to a mirror where the nmap author does not have access.  (Sourceforge claims it never bundles adware with security software, but that isn't at all reassuring.)

Please search the web for "sourceforge and gimp" and "sourceforge and nmap" and read a few of the relevant news items for further detailes.

Three suggestions:
1) We should migrate away from Sourceforge.
2) We should make sure the current Pd Sourceforge repo doesn't become inactive.
3) Once safely migrated, we should change to the Sourceforge code and release a Pd-extended binary on Sourceforge whose only function is to display a warning message to the user in the main Pd window. The warning should alert the user that Sourceforge is no longer the repo for any flavor of Pd, and that they should uninstall it and scan for malware.
4) We should maintain active accounts on Sourceforge to make sure the current binaries never become a target for delivering malware.


This may be true for the compiled binaries but I think the svn repository should be safe, no?
I don't think anyone could add malware to the repository without svn being aware of it.

That sounds reasonable.  But it also sounds reasonable that a repo catering to FLOSS would
refrain from wrapping old binaries in a malware installer.  So...

-Jonathan


Martin