Ok, then I see that 0.55 is coming real soon :)
> All this is worth continuing to think about.
Let's keep thinking about [clip~] then please. I did get rid of the one in Cyclone thinking and assuming vanilla's could also take signal inlets and, better yet, offer multichannel expansion. What would be the problem with it? In my PR I was careful to add different DSP states for whether there are signal connections or not (like [lop~]), so it uses the same slightly more efficient algorithm if no signals are connected.
And since the clock is ticking, and also about multichannel goodies, I wanna move on in my wish list to lobby for adding signal comparison/logical operators
https://github.com/pure-data/pure-data/pull/2054 seems like a very good feature addition for 0.55 and easy to take. I agree with Christoph that it is a bit silly that we currently need externals (zexy, cyclone) or [expr~] for these basic math operations, and he makes a strong point that these are (still) single channel. I can say I don't have plans at all to add multichannel awareness to Cyclone's objects, and that like [clip~] I would gladly deprecate them in favor of Vanilla objects. So please consider this as well.
Thanks